X-Git-Url: http://git.tremily.us/?a=blobdiff_plain;f=doc%2Ftodo%2FAuto-setup_and_maintain_Mercurial_wrapper_hooks.mdwn;h=94212966a738b65c59385a1ca575ac5f1989ccd0;hb=1d6086d80d6b953114b8001f7714888eac2c4e8a;hp=d03b7fe93d0a1810d5718dbae04f1449f7ddf47e;hpb=9a38ee9af141d89d08b8543b786acf98e88d4d0d;p=ikiwiki.git

diff --git a/doc/todo/Auto-setup_and_maintain_Mercurial_wrapper_hooks.mdwn b/doc/todo/Auto-setup_and_maintain_Mercurial_wrapper_hooks.mdwn
index d03b7fe93..94212966a 100644
--- a/doc/todo/Auto-setup_and_maintain_Mercurial_wrapper_hooks.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/Auto-setup_and_maintain_Mercurial_wrapper_hooks.mdwn
@@ -7,6 +7,22 @@ ikiwiki can keep track of lines in `hgrc` for which it is responsible by adding
 
 Two ways follow below. I prefer the long one. --[[Daniel Andersson]]
 
+> I comment myself: this can probably be solved without adding ad-hoc hooks and stuff (maybe not as "correct" as changing the config file only directly after wrappers have been generated, but good enough). I have a large rewrite of `mercurial.pm` ready, currently under local testing before I upload it for comments, trying to make it equal in function to `git.pm`. Comments below are of course welcome, but I will look into other ways of solving it later. Maybe `rcs_checkconfig` or `rcs_genwrapper` should host the `hgrc`-changing code. --[[Daniel Andersson]]
+
+>> Having a hook that runs after a wrapper is generated may well be a good
+>> thing anyway. In ikiwiki-hosting, there are some genwrapper hooks
+>> that don't add any code to the wrapper, but are there only to run at,
+>> essentially, that time.
+>> 
+>> With that said, here it seems like unnecessary complexity.
+>> Why is `mercurial_wrapper` configurable at all? Why not just always
+>> write it to a specific place relative to the srcdir, and always make
+>> the hgrc look there?
+>> 
+>> (Other rcs plugins have good reasons to make their wrappers
+>> configurable, because one might want the wrapper to run as a git
+>> post-update or post-commit hook.) --[[Joey]]
+
 Compact way (addresses only point 1)
 ------------------------------------
 [This patch at pastebin](http://pastebin.com/by9f4dwX) ([raw version](http://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=by9f4dwX)).
@@ -31,6 +47,12 @@ Create `$config{srcdir}/.hg/hgrc` with hook info during auto-installation script
 
 (Is there a security risk with relative paths?)
 
+> The code seems to assume that hg will be run from within the srcdir,
+> specifically the top of the srcdir. If it's run from somewhere else,
+> even a subdirectory, this will fail to find the wrapper, or could
+> run some other program. Unless mercurial always interprets these paths
+> as relative to the top of the repository? --[[Joey]]
+
 	@@ -187,6 +186,22 @@
 	 		die "ikiwiki --wrappers --setup $config{dumpsetup} failed";
 	 	}